What feedback do reviewers give when reviewing qualitative manuscripts? A focused mapping review and synthesis
| Authors | Oliver Rudolf Herber, Caroline Bradbury-Jones, Susanna Böling, Sarah Combes, Julian Hirt, Yvonne Koop, Ragnhild Nyhagen, Jessica Veldhuizen, Julie Taylor |
|---|---|
| Published in | BMC Medical Research Methodology |
| Publication date | 18 mei 2020 |
| Type | Article |
Summary
Background: Peer review is at the heart of the scientific process. With the advent of digitisation, journals started to offer electronic articles or publishing online only. A new philosophy regarding the peer review process found its way into academia: the open peer review. Open peer review as practiced by BioMed Central (BMC) is a type of peer review where the names of authors and reviewers are disclosed and reviewer comments are published alongside the article. A number of articles have been published to assess peer reviews using quantitative research. However, no studies exist that used qualitative methods to analyse the content of reviewers’ comments. Methods: A focused mapping review and synthesis (FMRS) was undertaken of manuscripts reporting qualitative research submitted to BMC open access journals from 1 January – 31 March 2018. Free-text reviewer comments were extracted from peer review reports using a 77-item classification system organised according to three key dimensions that represented common themes and sub-themes. A two stage analysis process was employed. First, frequency counts were undertaken that allowed revealing patterns across themes/sub-themes. Second, thematic analysis was conducted on selected themes of the narrative portion of reviewer reports. Results: A total of 107 manuscripts submitted to nine open-access journals were included in the FMRS. The frequency analysis revealed that among the 30 most frequently employed themes “writing criteria” (dimension II) is the top ranking theme, followed by comments in relation to the “methods” (dimension I). Besides that, some results suggest an underlying quantitative mindset of reviewers. Results are compared and contrasted in relation to established reporting guidelines for qualitative research to inform reviewers and authors of frequent feedback offered to enhance the quality of manuscripts. Conclusions: This FMRS has highlighted some important issues that hold lessons for authors, reviewers and editors. We suggest modifying the current reporting guidelines by including a further item called “Degree of data transformation” to prompt authors and reviewers to make a judgment about the appropriateness of the degree of data transformation in relation to the chosen analysis method. Besides, we suggest that completion of a reporting checklist on submission becomes a requirement.
Downloads en links
On this publication contributed
| Language | Engels |
|---|---|
| Published in | BMC Medical Research Methodology |
| Key words | open access publishing, peer review, manuscript review, qualitative analysis, qualitative research, synthesis, mapping |
| Digital Object Identifier | 10.1186/s12874-020-01005-y |
Neem contact met ons op
- Telefoon 088 481 81 81
- Email info@hu.nl
-
Stuur ons direct een bericht of voeg +97010241111 toe aan de contactlijst van je telefoon en stel je vraag via WhatsApp.
- Bereikbaar op ma t/m vrij 09.30 - 16.30 uur.